LGBTQ+ Book Bans and the Battle for Visibility and Inclusion

Booked, But Not Forgotten: LGBTQ+ Stories Face a New Chapter in the Culture Wars

In recent years, the surge in book bans targeting LGBTQ+ content has become one of the most heated fronts in the culture wars. Once sporadic, these challenges have evolved into well-coordinated, nationwide efforts to erase queer narratives from school curricula and public libraries. The American Library Association (ALA) reports that over 45% of all challenged books in 2022 featured LGBTQ+ characters or themes, a staggering increase from earlier decades when such content made up less than 3% of all challenges^{1 2}.

This battle isn’t just about limiting access to specific titles—it’s part of a broader strategy to suppress LGBTQ+ visibility, especially for queer youth who rely on these stories for affirmation and identity exploration. As books like Maia Kobabe’s Gender Queer and George M. Johnson’s All Boys Aren’t Blue become central targets, the message sent to LGBTQ+ students is clear: their stories, and by extension, their identities, are not welcome in public education​^{3 4}.

The Rise of Coordinated Attacks

Historically, challenges to books came from concerned parents who objected to specific content their children were exposed to in school. Today, that dynamic has shifted dramatically. Well-funded advocacy groups, such as Moms for Liberty, now compile and distribute lists of hundreds of books they deem inappropriate, pushing for mass bans at the local and state levels. This shift has contributed to an explosion of book challenges in states like Florida, Missouri, and Iowa⁵​ ⁶

The vague language in many of these state laws, such as those passed in Florida, often bans books with any reference to gender identity or sexual orientation under the guise of protecting children from “sexual content”​⁷​ ⁸. As a result, librarians and teachers find themselves navigating increasingly hostile environments, facing potential job loss or legal action if they fail to comply.

Part of a Larger Cultural Backlash

Book bans targeting LGBTQ+ content are not occurring in isolation—they are part of a broader cultural pushback against the rapid gains made by the LGBTQ+ community over the last few decades. In tandem with laws that restrict drag performances, gender-affirming healthcare, and the participation of trans athletes in sports, these book bans represent a concerted effort to reduce LGBTQ+ visibility in public life​⁹.

As noted by Michael Bronski, a professor at Harvard, these efforts stem from a backlash against the social progress made in areas like marriage equality and trans rights. Conservative groups are using legislative and cultural tactics to halt what they see as a loss of traditional values​¹⁰. By targeting LGBTQ+ books in schools, they aim to reshape the narratives that young people are exposed to, reinforcing narrow definitions of gender and sexuality.

Impact on Librarians, Educators, and Students

The consequences of these bans extend far beyond book removal. Educators and librarians who resist these challenges often face harassment, legal threats, or termination. Many schools and libraries now engage in “soft censorship,” preemptively avoiding the purchase of potentially controversial books to avoid the risk of backlash​¹¹. In one high-profile case, an Iowa teacher was placed on leave simply for assigning a story by Schuyler Bailar, a transgender author, sparking local outrage and media attention¹².

For LGBTQ+ students, the stakes are even higher. These books are often their only access to stories that reflect their experiences. Removing these stories sends a damaging message that their identities are not worthy of recognition, leading to increased feelings of isolation and erasure​¹³​ ¹⁴.

How You Can Take Action

Though the situation is dire, there are several ways you can join the fight against LGBTQ+ book bans:

1. Attend School Board and Library Meetings: Many of these decisions are made at the local level, where community input is critical. Show up, voice your support for inclusive curricula, and advocate for keeping diverse books on the shelves​¹⁵.
2. Support Advocacy Groups: Organizations like PEN America, the ACLU, and Lambda Legal are leading the legal fight against censorship. Your donations and involvement can help them continue their work¹⁶​ ¹⁷.
3. Participate in Banned Books Week: Events like “Let Freedom Read Day” encourage public engagement through rallies, read-ins, and social media campaigns. This annual event raises awareness about the importance of free expression and the dangers of censorship​.
4. Host a Read-In or Buy Banned Books: Hosting community events where people read from banned books can be a powerful act of resistance. Purchasing these books also directly supports the authors and keeps their stories alive​.
5. Engage on Social Media: Use platforms like Twitter, Instagram, and Facebook to spread awareness. Amplify hashtags like #LetFreedomRead and share stories of how these bans affect your community. The more people are informed, the harder it becomes for these challenges to go unnoticed​.

LGBTQ+ book bans are more than just a fight over literature—they’re about whose voices get to be heard and whose stories are deemed acceptable in public spaces. For LGBTQ+ youth, these books are lifelines, offering understanding, connection, and representation. As the fight continues, it’s more important than ever to speak up, stand with those on the frontlines, and ensure that the next generation can access the stories that reflect their lives.

1. https://www.washingtonblade.com/2024/09/25/advocacy-groups-mark-banned-books-week/ ↩︎
2. https://www.out.com/out-exclusives/fighting-lgbtq-book-bans ↩︎
3. ref 1. ↩︎
4. https://www.lgbtqnation.com/2024/09/book-bans-have-increased-nearly-200-florida-and-iowa-are-largely-to-blame/ ↩︎
5. ref 4. ↩︎
6. https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2023/06/lgbtq-book-challenges-are-on-the-rise-heres-why/ ↩︎
7. ref 2. ↩︎
8. ref 1. ↩︎
9. ref 6. ↩︎
10. ref 6. ↩︎
11. ref 1. ↩︎
12. ref 1. ↩︎
13. ref 2. ↩︎
14. ref 4. ↩︎
15. ref 1. ↩︎
16. ref 2. ↩︎
17. ref 6. ↩︎